What Changes do Online Movements bring to Politics?
What Changes do Online Movements bring to Politics?
Two Politics & Society students
: 10/12/22
Online movements have become very popular over the past couple of years on social media such as the Black Lives Matter movement. However for our Politics & Society project we had the question of whether these movements actually affect politics or not. In our investigations we would research several different online movements but three in particular: Black Lives Matter (BLM), the MeToo movement and Just Stop Oil. Key Thinkers from the P&S course Noam Chomsky and Samuel P. Huntington would impact our questioning of all data we would collect.
Firstly, to understand online movements we had to understand why they become popular. From our research we noticed a pattern that online movements often skyrocketed in popularity after a tragic incident. Examples include the sexual harassment allegations towards Harvey Weinstein causing women to tweet their experiences with the Me Too hashtag, the tragic murder of George Floyd caught on video sparking support for BLM and Just Stop Oil attributing their disruptive protests to climate change issues such as the floods in Pakistan displacing millions of people. These calamitous events have been seen to unite those most affected by the issue. Social media allows online movements to go viral quickly such as the MeToo movement being tweeted over a million times in the first 48 hours after Alyssa Milano's tweet. However change at government policy proves a much slower and harder process.
A lot can occur with an online movement as a result of newfound popularity. Common consequences of new online movements are protests and donations to support the cause. The video of George Floyd being choked by the cops knee (Derek Chauvin) had become symbolism for racist discrimination across the States. By June 6th 2020 , half a million people turned out in nearly 550 places across the United States to protest for the BLM movement. By the end of that year BLM had also received over 80$ million in donations.
Jack Power, an Irish Times journalist, believes the popularity gained by an online movement can empower more people to speak up about the issue which effects them. Regarding the MeToo movement he says “Before you might have had someone in a position in power such as a film producer sexually assault an actress early in their career and not get called out for it for years, whereas now they are being called out much more quickly. I think things like the MeToo movement causes for a lot more accountability with these cases a lot more likely to go public". With newfound popularity these movements start having demands for what they believe as justice. The MeToo movement called out dozens of celebrities for sexual allegations such as Kevin Spacey. This led to Harvey Weinstein and Bill Cosby facing time behind bars for their offences.
The Just Stop Oil movement lists its demand to the UK government on their website “That the UK government makes a statement that it will immediately halt all future licensing and consents for the exploration, development and production of fossil fuels in the UK”. With these demands the movement seem stubborn and have said they may start slashing pieces of art if their demands are not met. All the while the mainstream media corporations make money off reporting these movements and their coverage leading to more headlines and attention towards the issues. However, popularity towards these online movements does not equate to government change as a lot more is needed than popularity for laws to be passed into legislation.
Different high profile online movements have led to different changes in politics than others. The Black Lives Matter incident became viral after the murder of George Floyd and has led to laws, proposals, and public directives at all levels of government to address police misconduct and systemic racial bias in the United States. Some common reforms involve bans on chokeholds and no knock-off warrants and improvements to police data collection procedures. New conversations were also brought into politics such as whether the police should be defunded in the United States as a result.
The MeToo movement led to Harvey Weinstein being sentenced to 23 years in prison for rape and sexual assault, a sight the Hollywood mogul's multitude of accusers thought they would never see. As a result of the movement all lawmakers and staff in Congress must now take anti-harassment training every year.
Since October 1, nearly 12,000 officer shifts have been required to respond to the Just Stop Oil activist group, diverting attention from areas like knife crime. The movement has gained popularity on social media with their pages amounting to 99 thousand followers on Twitter and 40 thousand on Instagram. However, they may be in the limelight with some popularity but that has not meant change at government level. This is partially due to the movement not being in public majority favour. According to surveys conducted earlier this year, soon after Just Stop Oil was formed, 58% of UK adults support their demands, but 57% are against the group itself. Social scientists claim they need “sympathisers” such as celebrities who are willing to contribute money, facilities, equipment and access to media.
Piers Morgan on his talkshow referred to the people behind the movement as ‘Brats’ and told them to stop being ‘d*cks’. “Protests like this infuriate and irritate the very people that it is supposedly trying to persuade. If Just Stop Oil wants anyone to listen to them well let me give them some very very simple advice stop being d*cks”
With a lack of majority public support it is yet to seen if Just Stop Oil has had any impact on politics.
In summary online movements can have a great impact on politics and policies when approached with a peaceful yet meaningful message. The most affective online movements also unite the people who are affected most by the issue. These movements are not meant to cause drama but instead evoke change at government level.
Though the change online movements can bring in politics is often overdue and necessary to society some may argue that the awareness the movements raise is more important than the policies changed as a result.
1 in 4 women have experienced rape or attempted rape during their lifetimes, according to several national U.S. surveys and according to Jack Power one of the best things about the MeToo movement is it has “led to journalists investigating people who have had allegations for maybe over 20 years or so”.
Black Lives Matter shifted public opinion. For example, a 2017 Pew study found that 54% of white people viewed officer involved shootings involving Black people to be signs of a broader problem. Over 50% of white people think that policing has racial issues. This attitudinal shift created a policy window for local, state, and federal changes to policing and the criminal justice system.
In conclusion, the awareness raised by online movements can cause as big a change or be more important than the policy changes that can come with online movements. One of the most powerful things an online movement can do is cause public discussion around a certain topic in society.
Sources: Bibliography:
Bibliography:
Bibliography:
Interview:
Jack Power, Irish Times Journalist interview
https://docs.google.com/document/d/1nHXRMtWQGw7bCf_wG-1Jhd2aqMHxMDG496mOB-vXx7s/edit?usp=sharing
Books:
The Rise of Digital Repression: How Technology is Reshaping Power, Politics, and Resistance written by Steve Feldstein
Manufacturing Consent: The Political Economy Of The Mass Media written by Edward S. Herman and Noam Chomsky
The Clash Of Civilizations and The Remaking of World Order written by Samuel P. Huntington
Documentaries
The Greatest Lie Ever Sold: George Floyd and the Rise of BLM, written and directed by Candace Owens
George Floyd and Black Lives Matter-A BBC My World special
13th Netflix documentary directed by Ava DuVernay
She Said directed by Maria Schrader
Podcasts
Black Lives Matter #51: by Crash Course Black American History
Ep 466: Just Stop Oil by Sensemaker
Season 3#8| The Me Too Movement by The Awaken Podcast
https://www.cnbc.com/2020/06/25/trump-attacks-black-lives-matter-racial-justice-movement.html
https://apnews.com/article/black-lives-matter-90-million-finances-8a80cad199f54c0c4b9e74283d27366f
https://www.newyorker.com/news/our-columnists/i-didnt-know-is-not-a-defense-for-enabling-trump
https://www.washingtonpost.com/technology/2020/05/29/inside-twitter-trump-label/
https://www.ohchr.org/en/press-releases/2021/05/united-states-un-expert-decries-new-laws-targeting-peaceful-and-black-lives United Nations comments on new laws
Key thinkers book featuring Noam Chomsky and Samuel P. Huntington
https://www.folens.ie/sites/default/files/bulk_upload/TheoriesInAction/TIA_PEP_EBOOK/index.html
https://www.opendemocracy.net/en/just-stop-oil-extinction-rebellion-climate-protest/
Just Stop Oil
Just stop Oil protests
Their website where their aims and goals can be seen.
https://www.reddocklaw.com/6-impacts-of-the-metoo-movement-the-harvey-weinstein-case/
MeToo movement Harvey Weinstein case and policies changed as result of the movement.
https://www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2021/07/01/bill-cosby-released-metoo-movement/
https://www.theguardian.com/world/2017/oct/20/women-worldwide-use-hashtag-metoo-against-sexual-harassment
https://www.chicagotribune.com/lifestyles/ct-me-too-timeline-20171208-htmlstory.html
How the MeToo movement began in 2006.
https://news.sky.com/story/just-stop-oil-considers-slashing-famous-artworks-as-it-threatens-to-escalate-protests-12757133
Just Stop Oil report on Van Gough painting incident
Jack Power Irish Times Journalist interview
https://docs.google.com/document/d/1nHXRMtWQGw7bCf_wG-1Jhd2aqMHxMDG496mOB-vXx7s/edit?usp=sharing
Comments
Post a Comment